Element 4.9
Alternative proteins: cultivated meat, precision fermentation, insects and plants
- Sheet
- 4.9
- Chapter
- 4 Food and farming
- State
- Drafted
- Release
- 16 November 2026
- Editor
- Contributed by Praecise as open research
- Reviewers
- To be named at review
- Safety
- S2, as the chapter
- Licence
- CC BY-SA 4.0
- Resources
- 5
The element
- Requirement
The group knows which protein sources other than conventional livestock it can grow, make or buy legally where it is, and treats any new food as regulated until the authority of its place says otherwise. Food safety is at safety level S2: this text states the requirement and points to the regulator; it gives no production process.
- How to tell
- For each protein source considered, the group can name its legal status where it is.
- Land and feed per unit of protein are part of the diet plan; Our World in Data reports that meat and dairy take about 80 per cent of agricultural land (If the world adopted a plant-based diet, we would reduce global agricultural land use from 4 to 1 billion hectares).
- Anything served to others follows the five keys to safer food (Five keys to safer food (poster)).
- Options
- Plant proteins: pulses, grains, nuts and seeds grown in the crop plan (4.3). A plant-based world diet would need about 1 billion hectares of farmland instead of about 4.1 billion, as Our World in Data reports (If the world adopted a plant-based diet, we would reduce global agricultural land use from 4 to 1 billion hectares).
- Insects: black soldier fly larvae turn biowaste into animal feed (Black Soldier Fly Biowaste Processing: A Step-by-Step Guide). Insects for human food are regulated differently by country; Singapore has a separate insect framework linked from its novel food page (Novel food (Singapore Food Agency)).
- Cultivated meat: animal cells grown in culture. In the United States, FDA oversees cell collection, banks and growth and USDA-FSIS takes over at harvest for livestock and poultry, under a 2019 agreement; FDA lists completed pre-market consultations on 16 November 2022 (chicken cells), 21 March 2023 and 7 March 2025 (pork fat cells) (Human food made with cultured animal cells (US FDA)). In Singapore, cultivated meat is a novel food needing pre-market approval, an offence to supply without approval from 28 November 2025 (Novel food (Singapore Food Agency)).
- Precision fermentation: microbes engineered to make specific proteins. Singapore names it as a novel food (Novel food (Singapore Food Agency)). No community-scale process was found.
- Settled, open, contested
Settled: plant proteins need far less land per unit than meat (If the world adopted a plant-based diet, we would reduce global agricultural land use from 4 to 1 billion hectares); new foods need pre-market approval in the jurisdictions read (Human food made with cultured animal cells (US FDA), Novel food (Singapore Food Agency)). Open: cost and scale of cultivated meat; no open source on either was opened. Contested: whether cultivated meat and precision fermentation serve food sovereignty or concentrate control in a few firms.
The four stages
- Learn: legal status where the group is (Human food made with cultured animal cells (US FDA), Novel food (Singapore Food Agency)); land per diet (If the world adopted a plant-based diet, we would reduce global agricultural land use from 4 to 1 billion hectares).
- Design: protein plan by source, with pulses and grains first.
- Build: insect units for feed (Black Soldier Fly Biowaste Processing: A Step-by-Step Guide); cultivated meat and precision fermentation are industrial and bought, not built.
- Deploy: record what is eaten and from where (4.8).
Resources at each stage
1 Learn
Understand
- Black Soldier Fly Biowaste Processing: A Step-by-Step Guide Guide, S2
- Human food made with cultured animal cells (US FDA) Standard, S1
- If the world adopted a plant-based diet, we would reduce global agricultural land use from 4 to 1 billion hectares Paper, S0
- Novel food (Singapore Food Agency) Standard, S1
- Five keys to safer food (poster) Guide, S2
2 Design
Size and choose
4 Deploy
Install, run and measure
What changes between 30 adults and 300 people
At either scale, cultivated meat and precision fermentation are bought products, not something a community makes. Plant protein from the group's own fields and insect feed units scale with land and labour; at 300 people a black soldier fly unit can process the group's biowaste (Black Soldier Fly Biowaste Processing: A Step-by-Step Guide).
Reference designs
Open for contributions Designs with drawings, specifications and a bill of materials. Add to it
Parts list
Every resource that supports this element. Those marked External carry the label “External resource. Not made or verified by Public Protocol”.
| Resource | Type | Origin | Maturity | Safety | Licence, as stated at its source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Black Soldier Fly Biowaste Processing: A Step-by-Step Guide | Guide | External | Established | S2 | Not stated on the page opened |
| Human food made with cultured animal cells (US FDA) | Standard | External | Working | S1 | Not stated on the page opened |
| If the world adopted a plant-based diet, we would reduce global agricultural land use from 4 to 1 billion hectares | Paper | External | Established | S0 | CC BY 4.0 |
| Novel food (Singapore Food Agency) | Standard | External | Working | S1 | © 2026 Singapore Food Agency |
| Five keys to safer food (poster) | Guide | External | Established | S2 | Not stated on the page opened |
Depends on, and completes
It is one of 27 elements that complete Food and farming.
The standing questions
Who can afford this: pulses are cheap; novel products are priced by firms. Who does the work: growing pulses is ordinary farm work. Who decides: the regulator decides legality; the group decides its diet.
Environments
Every setting
legality, not climate, is the first limit for cultivated meat and precision fermentation, which are made indoors (Human food made with cultured animal cells (US FDA), Novel food (Singapore Food Agency)).
Plant proteins and insects by setting
no source found in this research; pulses for each climate belong to the crop elements and the environment profiles topic.
Safety
State and evidence
Drafted
An editor has written the element's text from the resources listed under it, citing them. It is checked when it is reviewed.
Evidence from a real place or system is recorded here, with what did not work. What the states mean
History
- Drafted in the release of 16 November 2026.