Element 20.12
Physical security by design: layout, lighting, doors and cameras
- Sheet
- 20.12
- State
- Drafted
- Release
- 16 November 2026
- Editor
- Contributed by Praecise as open research
- Reviewers
- To be named at review
- Safety
- S2, as the chapter
- Licence
- CC BY-SA 4.0
- Resources
- 5
The element
- Requirement
The community's homes, stores and shared assets are laid out, lit and closed so that crime is harder and less rewarding, using measures with evidence behind them, and any surveillance respects the people it records.
Caution: lighting runs on mains or battery systems, and doors and grilles carry structural loads. Installation follows the electrical and building rules of the place and is done by people qualified for it.
- How to tell
- Lighting of outdoor shared spaces is planned from evidence. In a randomised experiment in New York City public housing in 2016, temporary lights led to a reduction of at least 36 per cent in nighttime outdoor index crimes after accounting for spillovers (Reducing Crime Through Environmental Design: Evidence from a Randomized Experiment of Street Lighting in New York City).
- Any camera scheme has a stated purpose, a target and a reason. A 40-year systematic review found CCTV associated with a significant but modest fall in crime, largest and most consistent in car parks, larger where monitoring is active and where cameras are combined with other measures; the authors caution against using it alone (CCTV surveillance for crime prevention: a 40-year systematic review with meta-analysis).
- Camera schemes meet data protection law: in the EU, the GDPR principles (Article 5 GDPR: Principles relating to processing of personal data) and the EDPB guidelines on video devices (Guidelines 3/2019 on processing of personal data through video devices).
- Options
- Lighting of paths and shared spaces. The strongest single piece of experimental evidence found (Reducing Crime Through Environmental Design: Evidence from a Randomized Experiment of Street Lighting in New York City). Energy use enters the power budget (domain 5).
- Upgrading the environment. WHO names upgrading urban environments among approaches to preventing youth violence (Youth violence (WHO fact sheet)).
- Cameras, targeted and combined. On car parks and stores of value, with active monitoring and other measures alongside (CCTV surveillance for crime prevention: a 40-year systematic review with meta-analysis). For the devices, see the sensors and cameras chapter.
- Resistant doors and windows. No open source on tested resistance classes for doors, windows and shutters was opened, so no class is recommended here; an entry is wanted.
- Protective shelters. For hardened rooms and bunkers, see the protective shelters chapter.
- Settled, open, contested
Settled. Lighting and targeted cameras have measured effects (Reducing Crime Through Environmental Design: Evidence from a Randomized Experiment of Street Lighting in New York City, CCTV surveillance for crime prevention: a 40-year systematic review with meta-analysis). Open. Crime prevention through environmental design as a whole is widely practised, but no systematic review of it was opened, so its wider claims are not made here. No study was found for rural or very small settlements. Contested. Cameras: the review supports targeted use (CCTV surveillance for crime prevention: a 40-year systematic review with meta-analysis); recording members and visitors costs privacy and trust, and the law limits it (Article 5 GDPR: Principles relating to processing of personal data).
The four stages
Learn: the evidence on lighting and cameras (Reducing Crime Through Environmental Design: Evidence from a Randomized Experiment of Street Lighting in New York City, CCTV surveillance for crime prevention: a 40-year systematic review with meta-analysis). Design: map what is valuable, where incidents happen and at what hour (20.1); choose measures that fit. Build: by qualified installers to local rules. Deploy: measure incidents before and after; review any camera scheme against its stated purpose and the law (Guidelines 3/2019 on processing of personal data through video devices).
Resources at each stage
1 Learn
Understand
- Reducing Crime Through Environmental Design: Evidence from a Randomized Experiment of Street Lighting in New York City Paper, S2
- Article 5 GDPR: Principles relating to processing of personal data Standard, S1
- CCTV surveillance for crime prevention: a 40-year systematic review with meta-analysis Paper, S1
- Youth violence (WHO fact sheet) Reference design, S1
2 Design
Size and choose
- Reducing Crime Through Environmental Design: Evidence from a Randomized Experiment of Street Lighting in New York City Paper, S2
- Guidelines 3/2019 on processing of personal data through video devices Guide, S1
- Article 5 GDPR: Principles relating to processing of personal data Standard, S1
- CCTV surveillance for crime prevention: a 40-year systematic review with meta-analysis Paper, S1
4 Deploy
Install, run and measure
What changes between 30 adults and 300 people
At 30 adults the work is a walk round at night, lights on paths, sound locks on the store and the tool shed, and no cameras unless a clear problem calls for them. At 300 people layout is part of site planning, lighting is a utility, any camera scheme is a governance decision with a written assessment, and incident records drive changes.
Reference designs
-
Reference design
Youth violence (WHO fact sheet)
A WHO fact sheet dated 8 May 2026. It states that about 193,000 homicides a year occur among people aged 15 to 29, and names prevention approaches including parenting programmes, life skills and social development programmes, reducing access to alcohol, community and problem-oriented policing, and upgrading urban environments.
External resource. Not made or verified by Public ProtocolMaturity: EstablishedSafety S1Listed 16 November 2026
Parts list
Every resource that supports this element. Those marked External carry the label “External resource. Not made or verified by Public Protocol”.
| Resource | Type | Origin | Maturity | Safety | Licence, as stated at its source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Reducing Crime Through Environmental Design: Evidence from a Randomized Experiment of Street Lighting in New York City | Paper | External | Working | S2 | Not stated on the page opened |
| Guidelines 3/2019 on processing of personal data through video devices | Guide | External | Established | S1 | Not stated on the page opened |
| Article 5 GDPR: Principles relating to processing of personal data | Standard | External | Established | S1 | Not stated on the page opened |
| CCTV surveillance for crime prevention: a 40-year systematic review with meta-analysis | Paper | External | Established | S1 | Not stated on the page opened |
| Youth violence (WHO fact sheet) | Reference design | External | Established | S1 | Not stated on the page opened |
Depends on, and completes
Depends on 20.1.
It is one of 12 elements that complete Safety, resilience and disaster readiness.
The standing questions
Who can afford this: lights and locks are modest; monitored cameras are not. Who does the work: a safety group with the site planners. Who decides: cameras and recording are for the whole community (15.2), and nobody is recorded in their home or in places where privacy is expected.
Environments
For islands and coasts, arctic cold, hot deserts, tropical humid forest, temperate forest, high altitude and flood plains: no source found on how setting changes the effect of lighting or cameras. The lighting evidence comes from dense city housing (Reducing Crime Through Environmental Design: Evidence from a Randomized Experiment of Street Lighting in New York City); whether it transfers to dispersed settlements is not known.
Safety
State and evidence
Drafted
An editor has written the element's text from the resources listed under it, citing them. It is checked when it is reviewed.
Evidence from a real place or system is recorded here, with what did not work. What the states mean
History
- Drafted in the release of 16 November 2026.