Element 21.7
Keeping fish farming from harming wild waters
- Sheet
- 21.7
- State
- Drafted
- Release
- 16 November 2026
- Editor
- Contributed by Praecise as open research
- Reviewers
- To be named at review
- Safety
- S1, as the chapter
- Licence
- CC BY-SA 4.0
- Resources
- 12
The element
- Requirement
Any fish or shellfish farm the group runs does not destroy mangroves or wetlands, does not let farmed animals escape into wild populations, does not spread disease or drugs into the water, and returns its nutrient waste to use rather than to the river or bay.
- How to tell
The site record shows no mangrove or wetland cleared. Containment is checked and any escape is recorded and reported. Drug use is prescribed and recorded. Effluent is measured or routed to plants, seaweed or filter feeders. Where farms are certified, the farm standard sets these checks (Aquaculture Stewardship Council (ASC)).
- Options
- Siting. Most mangrove loss from 2000 to 2016 came from land-use change, mainly aquaculture and agriculture, concentrated in six Southeast Asian nations (Global declines in human-driven mangrove loss). Spatial planning can place farms where impacts on other uses are small (Marine spatial planning makes room for offshore aquaculture in crowded coastal waters).
- Containment and stock choice. Farmed salmon escapees have bred into about two-thirds of 250 Norwegian wild salmon populations studied (Genetic markers for tracing introgression of farmed Atlantic salmon in wild conspecifics); higher farmed ancestry changes growth and age at migration and maturity (Introgression from farmed escapees affects the full life cycle of wild Atlantic salmon); domesticated salmon survived about half as well as wild salmon in a river experiment (An extensive common-garden study with domesticated and wild Atlantic salmon in the wild). The sources opened here document the harm, not tested remedies; better marker panels exist to monitor it (Genetic markers for tracing introgression of farmed Atlantic salmon in wild conspecifics).
- Waste to food. Fed fish waste can feed worms, seaweed or shellfish: ragworm filters removed about 70 per cent of particulate organic matter in a land-based system (Polychaete-assisted sand filters in a land-based integrated multi-trophic aquaculture system under contrasting nutrient loads); Gracilaria takes up nitrogen from shrimp farm wastewater (Biology, farming and applications of the red seaweed Gracilaria edulis: a concise review).
- Fewer drugs. Antimicrobial use in aquaculture was estimated at about 10,259 tonnes in 2017 and projected to rise (Global trends in antimicrobial use in aquaculture).
- Settled, open, contested
Settled: aquaculture has driven mangrove loss (Global declines in human-driven mangrove loss); farmed salmon escapes have changed wild populations (Genetic markers for tracing introgression of farmed Atlantic salmon in wild conspecifics). Open: the effect of farm sea lice on wild salmon at zone scale. Norway's zone system relies on predicted lice density, and a 2025 re-analysis found that prediction a poor guide to lice on wild sea trout (Prediction of salmon lice density on wild sea trout from mean predicted lice density in the sea: a cross-validation); this research found no open quantified estimate of lice effects on wild returns. Lice treatments are associated with deaths of farmed salmon themselves (Factors associated with baseline mortality in Norwegian Atlantic salmon farming). Contested: open net pens. One position holds they should move to land or closed systems; the other that recirculating systems trade these harms for high energy use (see the recirculating systems element).
The four stages
Learn: documented impacts (Global declines in human-driven mangrove loss, Genetic markers for tracing introgression of farmed Atlantic salmon in wild conspecifics, A 20-year retrospective review of global aquaculture). Design: site and system to avoid them (Marine spatial planning makes room for offshore aquaculture in crowded coastal waters). Build: containment and nutrient capture (Polychaete-assisted sand filters in a land-based integrated multi-trophic aquaculture system under contrasting nutrient loads). Deploy: records of escapes, drugs and effluent; audit where certified (Aquaculture Stewardship Council (ASC)).
Resources at each stage
1 Learn
Understand
- Biology, farming and applications of the red seaweed Gracilaria edulis: a concise review Paper, S0
- Introgression from farmed escapees affects the full life cycle of wild Atlantic salmon Paper, S0
- Prediction of salmon lice density on wild sea trout from mean predicted lice density in the sea: a cross-validation Paper, S0
- Global declines in human-driven mangrove loss Paper, S0
- Genetic markers for tracing introgression of farmed Atlantic salmon in wild conspecifics Paper, S0
- Polychaete-assisted sand filters in a land-based integrated multi-trophic aquaculture system under contrasting nutrient loads Paper, S0
- Marine spatial planning makes room for offshore aquaculture in crowded coastal waters Paper, S0
- A 20-year retrospective review of global aquaculture Paper, S0
- Factors associated with baseline mortality in Norwegian Atlantic salmon farming Paper, S1
- Global trends in antimicrobial use in aquaculture Paper, S1
- An extensive common-garden study with domesticated and wild Atlantic salmon in the wild Paper, S0
2 Design
Size and choose
What changes between 30 adults and 300 people
At 30 adults, impacts are small but the rules are the same: no clearing, no escapes of non-native fish, no drug use without advice. At 300 people, effluent and escapes become regulated matters, with permits, monitoring and possibly certification.
Reference designs
Open for contributions Designs with drawings, specifications and a bill of materials. Add to it
Parts list
Every resource that supports this element. Those marked External carry the label “External resource. Not made or verified by Public Protocol”.
Depends on, and completes
The chapter as a whole needs no other chapter.
It is one of 7 elements that complete Ecology, biodiversity and climate.
The standing questions
Who can afford this: closed systems and monitoring cost more. Who does the work: daily containment checks. Who decides: neighbours, wild fishers and authorities share the water and the decision.
Environments
mangroves (Global declines in human-driven mangrove loss); salmon escapes in Norway and Iceland (Genetic markers for tracing introgression of farmed Atlantic salmon in wild conspecifics).
the Norwegian and Icelandic evidence applies to cold northern waters (Genetic markers for tracing introgression of farmed Atlantic salmon in wild conspecifics).
- Hot deserts, tropical humid forest, temperate forest, high altitude, flood plains: no source found.
Environment profiles for these settings: Small islands and coasts; Arctic, subarctic and permafrost, including sea ice. All environments
Safety
State and evidence
Drafted
An editor has written the element's text from the resources listed under it, citing them. It is checked when it is reviewed.
Evidence from a real place or system is recorded here, with what did not work. What the states mean
History
- Drafted in the release of 16 November 2026.