Governance
Contributions to Public Platform go through a review phase carried out by the governance board. The board is elected, at first from among the contributors, developers, academics, researchers and others contributing to Public Protocol. Projects are submitted and reviewed the same way.
The board is being formed. Joining the community and contributing is how a person comes to vote and to stand. Join and contribute
Everything below is proposed by Public Protocol to make that decision work, and is confirmed by Public Protocol and the first board.
What the board does
The board reviews contributions, by delegating routine review to reviewers it appoints. It keeps the blueprint coherent: the structure of domains and elements, the principles as applied, the form of an element. It approves releases, settles disputes over content, sets safety policy, appoints and removes reviewers and stewards, and publishes its decisions with reasons.
What stays with Public Protocol as host
Public Protocol keeps what a host answers for in law: compliance and lawful takedowns; emergency removal of content that is dangerous or unlawful, reported to the board, which may reverse it unless the law forbids; the organisation's money, staff, infrastructure and contracts; its names and marks; who is named as a founding partner or a supporter, and the signing of partner agreements. The host does not overrule the board on content except on those legal and safety grounds, and says so publicly when it does.
Seats
Nine seats once elected.
| Seats | Kind |
|---|---|
| 2 | Practitioners in the physical domains: people who build, grow, repair and install |
| 2 | Developers and engineers: software, hardware, infrastructure |
| 2 | Academics and researchers |
| 2 | At large, elected by all voters, to cover governance, economy, health, education and other domains |
| 1 | Named by Public Protocol as host, with a vote, to carry the legal and safety duties into the room |
Terms
Two years, with half the elected seats chosen each year. At most two consecutive terms, then a year out. No more than two members from one organisation or its affiliates. Members from commercial or partner organisations together hold fewer than half the seats.
Who votes and who stands
A voter is a contributor with at least three accepted contributions in the previous twelve months, or one substantial one: an element drafted, a framework, a reference design, a reviewed translation of a chapter, or twelve months' service as a reviewer. The count comes from the platform's own record. Corrections count; reports alone do not.
A candidate is a voter of at least six months' standing who publishes a statement and a declaration of interests. The roll of voters is published before each election.
The first board
A provisional board of five, named by Public Protocol from people already contributing across the kinds of seat, each published with a declaration of interests, for a fixed term that ends at the first election.
The first election is held when the roll reaches thirty voters. The position is reported publicly at twelve months in any case.
Voting
One person, one vote, by secret ballot. Approval voting within each group of seats: a voter marks every candidate they accept, and the most approved take the seats. The tally and the turnout are published.
Interests, recall and vacancies
Declarations of interest are public and kept current. A member takes no part in a decision on their own or their organisation's contribution, product or competitor, and the record shows it. No seat is tied to money.
A recall vote is held if a tenth of voters ask, and succeeds with two thirds of the votes cast. A member who is inactive in review for three months vacates the seat.
Who decides what, and by when
A contribution that is not decided in time moves up a level. A contributor may appeal a decision once, to the board, within thirty days.
| Level | Who | Decides | Within |
|---|---|---|---|
| Triage | An editor | Nothing. Checks completeness, licence and duplicates, routes to a domain, proposes labels | 7 days |
| Routine review | Two reviewers of the domain's review group, appointed by the board for a year | Listings of external resources at S0 and S1; corrections; translations; case studies; guides without safety consequences; label changes with evidence | 21 days |
| The board, or a panel of three it names with at least one person qualified in the subject | Anything at S2 or S3; frameworks; the text and state of elements; changes to structure, principles and policy; releases; systems and commercial listings; projects; partner requests | 45 days |
In the open
Agendas ahead of time, minutes within two weeks, and every decision recorded with its reason, the vote and any recusal, linked from the entries it concerns. An annual report gives contributions received, time to decision, appeals and removals. Personal data, security matters and legal advice stay private.
What a model may do in review
A model may help with triage, checks that sources exist and say what is claimed, licence checks, finding duplicates, and drafts for editors. It never approves and never sets a label without a person confirming, and its drafts are marked. At safety levels S2 and S3 nothing machine-drafted enters an element's text.
The states a visitor sees
- ListedListed by Public Protocol's editors at the founding of the catalogue: the source was opened, described in our own words and labelled on the date shown. It goes to the governance board's reviewers with everything else.
- SubmittedReceived and waiting for triage. Only its title, type and date are shown.
- In reviewWith reviewers. The level it is at and the date a decision is due are shown.
- ReviewedApproved. The entry names who reviewed it, in what capacity and when, and links to the decision.
- Proven in useReviewed, and followed in a real place or system, with the evidence.