Element 4.19
Recirculating systems and aquaponics
- Sheet
- 4.19
- Chapter
- 4 Food and farming
- State
- Drafted
- Release
- 16 November 2026
- Editor
- Contributed by Praecise as open research
- Reviewers
- To be named at review
- Safety
- S2, as the chapter
- Licence
- CC BY-SA 4.0
- Resources
- 7
The element
- Requirement
Fish raised in tanks with recirculated water, alone or with plants, have oxygen, filtration and temperature held within their needs at all times, with backup for power failure, and produce sold or shared is safe to eat. Pumps, heaters and aerators run on mains power next to water: electrical work follows the wiring rules of the place and is done or checked by a qualified person (domain 5).
- How to tell
Electricity and water use are metered and recorded per kilogram of fish. A systematic review of 25 datasets reports average electricity use of 7.49 kWh per kg of fish in freshwater and 14.53 kWh per kg in saltwater recirculating systems, as summarised from the paper (In search of electricity use patterns for resource-efficient fish farming in recirculating aquaculture systems: a systematic review). There is a written plan for a power or pump failure. Crops grown on fish water are handled to the WHO Five keys (Five keys to safer food (poster)), since a systematic review found coliforms and Shiga toxin-producing E. coli on aquaponic lettuce (Microbiological contamination of lettuce reared with tilapia in aquaponic systems: a systematic review).
- Options
- Recirculating aquaculture systems (RAS). Water is filtered and reused in tanks. A life cycle assessment of a commercial tilapia and African catfish farm in Sweden found feed caused 67 to 98 per cent of impacts in most categories, with energy demand the exception for tilapia (Recirculating aquaculture is possible without major energy tradeoff: life cycle assessment of warmwater fish farming in Sweden). Fits cold climates, little land, or no natural water body.
- Low-technology aquaponics. Fish water feeds vegetables. In a low-technology pilot with European carp, water lost to evapotranspiration was about 1.37 per cent of system water a day, lettuce yielded about 4.0 kg per square metre, and the higher fish density gave lower vegetable yields (Effect of stocking density of fish on water quality and growth performance of European carp and leafy vegetables in a low-tech aquaponic system).
- Aquaponics for herbs and leafy crops. Watercress in aquaponics used 34.4 per cent less water a day than in soil and yielded 81 per cent more; economic feasibility was not assessed (Comparing yield, nutrient uptake and water use efficiency of Nasturtium officinale cultivated in aquaponic, hydroponic and soil systems).
- Controlled ponds and tanks. Predictive control cut energy by 26.86 per cent against manual operation in a 45-day koi pond trial (An intelligent IoT-based predictive control system for water quality and energy management in koi aquaculture).
- Settled, open, contested
Settled: recirculation saves water but needs continuous power; feed dominates most impacts (Recirculating aquaculture is possible without major energy tradeoff: life cycle assessment of warmwater fish farming in Sweden). Open: how far the review's averages hold for any one farm, and water use per kilogram; this research found no open figure for RAS water use (In search of electricity use patterns for resource-efficient fish farming in recirculating aquaculture systems: a systematic review). Contested: whether small aquaponics pays. One position holds that combined fish and vegetables use water and nutrients better; the other that the economics are unproven, which the watercress authors acknowledge (Comparing yield, nutrient uptake and water use efficiency of Nasturtium officinale cultivated in aquaponic, hydroponic and soil systems).
The four stages
Learn: energy and impact figures (In search of electricity use patterns for resource-efficient fish farming in recirculating aquaculture systems: a systematic review, Recirculating aquaculture is possible without major energy tradeoff: life cycle assessment of warmwater fish farming in Sweden). Design: size fish density to the plant area (Effect of stocking density of fish on water quality and growth performance of European carp and leafy vegetables in a low-tech aquaponic system); plan power supply and backup with domain 5. Build: tanks, filters, pumps and wiring by a qualified person. Deploy: meter power and water, record fish and crop yields, and handle produce safely (Five keys to safer food (poster), Microbiological contamination of lettuce reared with tilapia in aquaponic systems: a systematic review).
Resources at each stage
1 Learn
Understand
- Comparing yield, nutrient uptake and water use efficiency of Nasturtium officinale cultivated in aquaponic, hydroponic and soil systems Paper, S2
- Recirculating aquaculture is possible without major energy tradeoff: life cycle assessment of warmwater fish farming in Sweden Paper, S2
- Microbiological contamination of lettuce reared with tilapia in aquaponic systems: a systematic review Paper, S2
- In search of electricity use patterns for resource-efficient fish farming in recirculating aquaculture systems: a systematic review Paper, S2
- An intelligent IoT-based predictive control system for water quality and energy management in koi aquaculture Paper, S2
- Effect of stocking density of fish on water quality and growth performance of European carp and leafy vegetables in a low-tech aquaponic system Paper, S2
- Five keys to safer food (poster) Guide, S2
2 Design
Size and choose
What changes between 30 adults and 300 people
At 30 adults, a small aquaponic unit in a greenhouse (4.5) is a learning project and supplement. At 300 people, a RAS large enough to supply regular fish is an energy load to plan with domain 5: at the review's average of 7.49 kWh per kg in freshwater (In search of electricity use patterns for resource-efficient fish farming in recirculating aquaculture systems: a systematic review), each tonne of fish needs on the order of 7,500 kWh, plus feed and backup power. No source gives community-scale sizing.
Reference designs
Open for contributions Designs with drawings, specifications and a bill of materials. Add to it
Parts list
Every resource that supports this element. Those marked External carry the label “External resource. Not made or verified by Public Protocol”.
Depends on, and completes
It is one of 27 elements that complete Food and farming.
The standing questions
Who can afford this: tanks, pumps and electricity are recurring costs. Who does the work: daily checks; alarms at night. Who decides: the group decides whether the energy is worth the fish.
Environments
no source found specific to this setting.
a commercial warm-water RAS operates in Sweden (Recirculating aquaculture is possible without major energy tradeoff: life cycle assessment of warmwater fish farming in Sweden).
no source found for RAS here; water savings of aquaponics over soil are documented (Comparing yield, nutrient uptake and water use efficiency of Nasturtium officinale cultivated in aquaponic, hydroponic and soil systems).
- Tropical humid forest, temperate forest, high altitude, flood plains: no source found.
Environment profiles for these settings: Small islands and coasts; Arctic, subarctic and permafrost, including sea ice; Extreme cold; Hot deserts; Extreme heat. All environments
Safety
State and evidence
Drafted
An editor has written the element's text from the resources listed under it, citing them. It is checked when it is reviewed.
Evidence from a real place or system is recorded here, with what did not work. What the states mean
History
- Drafted in the release of 16 November 2026.