Public Protocol
Platform

Element 4.16

Soilless growing: hydroponics, aeroponics and aquaponics

Sheet
4.16
Chapter
4 Food and farming
State
Drafted
Release
16 November 2026
Editor
Contributed by Praecise as open research
Reviewers
To be named at review
Safety
S2, as the chapter
Licence
CC BY-SA 4.0
Resources
9

The element

Requirement

Where the group grows plants without soil, the system is chosen for the crop and the power and water available, its nutrient solution is monitored, and its failure modes (pump stops, power cuts, root disease) have a planned response. Pumps, heaters and lights near water are an electrical hazard: wiring follows the electrical safety element and the standards it cites. Produce eaten raw follows the food safety element (Five keys to safer food (poster)).

How to tell
  • Each system has a written description: type, crop, volume of solution, how often it is checked, and what happens if power fails.
  • Electrical conductivity, pH and temperature of the solution are logged; an open controller can log and act on sensor readings (Mycodo).
  • Yields and inputs are recorded (4.8), so the system can be compared with soil beds.
Options

Sources for this element are thin. This research opened no peer-reviewed source that compares the hydroponic methods below, so each is described by what it is and figures are given only where a source was opened.

  • Non-circulating (Kratky) hydroponics: lined tanks are filled once with nutrient solution, seedlings in net pots sit just in it, and roots above the falling solution take air from the humid gap; no pumps or electricity are needed. The University of Hawaii publication limits it to crops needing under 2 gallons of water per plant for the season, such as lettuce, cilantro, green onions, pak choi and watercress, and states that rain shelters are needed in rainy places, because rain raises the solution and drowns the air roots (A suspended net-pot, non-circulating hydroponic method for commercial production of leafy, romaine, and semi-head lettuce (Kratky, 2010)). It is the simplest option where power is unreliable.
  • Deep water culture, nutrient film technique, ebb and flow, drip and wick systems: recirculating or flooding systems with pumps. No open source was opened in this research.
  • Aeroponics: roots hang in air and are misted. One maker of ultrasonic aeroponic benches states yields over 20 per cent higher than hydroponics and lower water, fertiliser and disease pressure, citing validation by Wageningen University and Research, but publishes no trial data on the page (Aeroponic technology (LettUs Grow)). Treat as a maker's claim. Nozzle clogging and loss of misting are the failure risks the maker designs against (Aeroponic technology (LettUs Grow)).
  • Aquaponics: fish waste feeds plants through bacteria that convert ammonia to nitrate. The fish side belongs to the aquaculture topic. FAO's Technical Paper 589 (2014) covers media bed, nutrient film and deep water culture units and balances them by feed, not fish: 40 to 50 grams of fish feed per square metre of growing space per day for leafy greens and 50 to 80 for fruiting vegetables, as a guide only, with pH kept at 6 to 7 as a compromise between plants, fish and bacteria; electricity is generally needed to circulate or oxygenate the water (Small-scale aquaponic food production: integrated fish and plant farming (FAO Fisheries and Aquaculture Technical Paper 589)).
  • Fogponics: no source found.
  • Substrates (coir, rockwool, perlite, biochar): no source opened.
  • Automation: open hardware can automate small beds (FarmBot); microcontrollers read sensors (Arduino Documentation).
Settled, open, contested

Settled: monitor the solution, plan for power failure, wire to code. Open: independent, peer-reviewed comparisons of yield, water and energy per kilogram between hydroponic methods and aeroponics; none was opened in this work. Contested: whether aeroponics outperforms hydroponics. Makers state it does (Aeroponic technology (LettUs Grow)); this research found no open trial data to settle it.

The four stages

Resources at each stage

What changes between 30 adults and 300 people

At 30 adults, a few non-circulating tanks under a rain shelter give salad greens with no pumps (A suspended net-pot, non-circulating hydroponic method for commercial production of leafy, romaine, and semi-head lettuce (Kratky, 2010)), or a small aquaponic unit sized by the feed rate ratio (Small-scale aquaponic food production: integrated fish and plant farming (FAO Fisheries and Aquaculture Technical Paper 589)). At 300 people, a recirculating system or container farm becomes infrastructure with daily operators, spare pumps, backup power and an energy budget in domain 5; one failed pump can lose a whole crop.

Reference designs

  • Reference design

    FarmBot

    An open-source machine that plants, waters and weeds a raised bed. Its maker sells kits and publishes the designs, the software and the documentation.

    External resource. Not made or verified by Public ProtocolMaturity: Not assessedSafety S1Open, with paid products or servicesListed 16 November 2026

Parts list

Every resource that supports this element. Those marked External carry the label “External resource. Not made or verified by Public Protocol”.

ResourceTypeOriginMaturitySafetyLicence, as stated at its source
Arduino DocumentationGuideExternalEstablishedS0Not stated on the page opened
Small-scale aquaponic food production: integrated fish and plant farming (FAO Fisheries and Aquaculture Technical Paper 589)GuideExternalEstablishedS2© FAO, 2014. Material may be copied, downloaded and printed for private study, research and teaching, or for use in non-commercial products or services, with acknowledgement of FAO; commercial and adaptation rights on request
FarmBotReference designExternalNot assessedS1As stated for each component: hardware to the open-source hardware definition, software under permissive open-source licences, open documentation
A suspended net-pot, non-circulating hydroponic method for commercial production of leafy, romaine, and semi-head lettuce (Kratky, 2010)GuideExternalReplicatedS1Not stated on the pages read
From physics to fixtures to food: current and potential LED efficacy (Kusuma, Pattison and Bugbee, 2020)PaperExternalEstablishedS1Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)
Aeroponic technology (LettUs Grow)ToolExternalWorkingS1Not stated on the page opened
Solar daylighting to offset LED lighting in vertical farming: a techno-economic study of light pipes (Ceccanti and others, 2026)PaperExternalConceptS0CC BY-NC-ND 4.0
MycodoToolExternalWorkingS1GNU GPL v3 or later
Five keys to safer food (poster)GuideExternalEstablishedS2Not stated on the page opened

Depends on, and completes

Depends on 4.5, 4.2, 4.7.

It is one of 27 elements that complete Food and farming.

The standing questions

Who can afford this: pumps, sensors, lights and power are recurring costs. Who does the work: someone checks every day. Who decides: the growing group, within the energy budget the group agrees.

Environments

Environment profiles for these settings: Hot deserts; Extreme heat; Arctic, subarctic and permafrost, including sea ice; Extreme cold; Underground and enclosed spaces; Tropical rainforest and humid tropics; Temperate and boreal forests; Mountains and high altitude; River deltas and flood plains. All environments

Safety

State and evidence

Drafted

An editor has written the element's text from the resources listed under it, citing them. It is checked when it is reviewed.

Evidence from a real place or system is recorded here, with what did not work. What the states mean

History